7 Bold NHL Trade Deadline Predictions for the 2025 Season

As the 2025 NHL trade deadline approaches, the line between Stanley Cup contenders and hopeful rebuilders becomes sharply defined. Teams are meticulously analysing their rosters, identifying crucial gaps that a single strategic acquisition could fill. Whether it's a shutdown defenceman for the penalty kill, a veteran goaltender for playoff insurance, or a pure goal-scorer to ignite a stagnant power play, the right move can alter the championship landscape. This year's market is particularly rich with talent, featuring high-impact rentals on expiring contracts and cornerstone players with term who could be convinced to waive no-trade clauses for a legitimate shot at the Cup.

In this comprehensive breakdown, we will dive deep into our top NHL trade deadline predictions, exploring the intricate details behind each potential deal. This is not just a list of names; it's a detailed analysis of the moving parts that make trades happen. We will examine player metrics, specific team needs, complex salary cap implications, and the likely return packages that will be required to get these deals over the finish line. Consider this your front-row seat to the league's most exciting chess match. Let's explore the seven biggest names most likely to find a new home and dissect where they might ultimately land.

1. Jacob Markstrom Trade from Calgary Flames

Among the most talked-about nhl trade deadline predictions, the departure of veteran goaltender Jacob Markstrom from the Calgary Flames stands out. As the Flames pivot towards a retool or full rebuild, trading a 34-year-old elite netminder on a significant contract makes strategic sense. For contending teams, Markstrom represents a substantial upgrade and a source of stability in the crease, making him arguably the most impactful player available.

A trade for Markstrom is the ultimate "win-now" move. Teams with solid skater groups but shaky goaltending see him as the final piece of the puzzle. His experience and stellar performance metrics provide the kind of playoff insurance that can turn a good team into a great one. This scenario is reminiscent of past deadline acquisitions where a proven goalie was brought in to backstop a deep playoff run, such as the trades involving Roberto Luongo or Ben Bishop in years prior.

Why Markstrom is a Top Target

Markstrom isn't just a capable starter; he's a game-changer. His ability to steal games and provide a calming presence is invaluable, especially in the high-pressure environment of the Stanley Cup Playoffs. His performance this season has been exceptional, often keeping a transitioning Flames team competitive against top-tier opponents.

This infographic provides a quick reference to his elite performance metrics and contract details.

These numbers illustrate why general managers are willing to pay a premium; Markstrom delivers Vezina-calibre goaltending with term, offering more than just a rental.

Actionable Insights for Contenders

Teams looking to acquire Markstrom must consider several factors beyond just the trade cost. Here are some key strategic points:

• Evaluate Salary Retention: Calgary may need to retain a portion of his $6 million AAV to facilitate a deal with a cap-strapped contender. This will significantly increase the asking price, likely demanding a first-round pick plus a high-end prospect.
• Assess Goaltending Need: Is your current goaltending tandem susceptible to inconsistency or injury? A team like the New Jersey Devils or Colorado Avalanche could see Markstrom as the definitive answer to their goaltending questions.
• Consider the Term: Unlike a typical rental, Markstrom is signed through 2025-26. This provides a multi-year window of contention but also requires a longer-term commitment to a goaltender in his mid-30s.

Ultimately, trading for Markstrom is a high-stakes play. It demands a significant package of assets but offers a rare opportunity to acquire a top-five goaltender at the deadline, potentially altering the entire championship landscape.

2. Chris Tanev Rental Move from Calgary

Among the most certain nhl trade deadline predictions is that veteran defenceman Chris Tanev will be moved by the Calgary Flames. As an expiring unrestricted free agent on a rebuilding team, Tanev is the quintessential rental player. His elite shot-blocking, penalty-killing prowess, and stay-at-home defensive style make him an invaluable addition for any Stanley Cup contender seeking to fortify its blue line for a gruelling playoff run.

A trade for Tanev is a low-risk, high-reward move for a contender looking for immediate defensive stability. Teams with high-octane offences but porous defences see him as the perfect balancing element. This scenario is comparable to past deadline deals where shutdown specialists were acquired to handle tough matchups, such as David Savard’s move to Tampa Bay in 2021, which played a key role in their championship.

Why Tanev is a Top Target

Tanev isn't a flashy, point-producing defenceman; he is a pure defensive specialist who excels in the game’s toughest areas. His value lies in his high hockey IQ, fearless shot-blocking, and ability to neutralize the opposition's top forwards. He consistently logs difficult minutes against elite competition and is a mainstay on the penalty kill, making him an ideal second-pairing defenceman for a playoff-bound team. His experience and rugged style are custom-made for the postseason.

Actionable Insights for Contenders

Teams pursuing Tanev need to understand they are acquiring a specific, role-playing asset. Here are the key strategic considerations:

• Assess Defensive Structure: Does your team need a stabilizing presence on the back end? Teams like the Toronto Maple Leafs, Edmonton Oilers, or Vancouver Canucks could greatly benefit from a reliable, right-shot defenceman who can handle pressure.
• Evaluate the Cost: As a pure rental, Tanev won't command the same price as a player with term. However, the high demand for right-shot defencemen could still drive the price to a first-round pick or a combination of a second-round pick and a quality prospect.
• Prioritize Penalty Kill Improvement: If your special teams are a weak point, Tanev provides an immediate and significant upgrade. His expertise on the penalty kill can be the difference in a tight playoff series where a single goal can shift momentum.

Ultimately, acquiring Chris Tanev is a pragmatic and intelligent move for a team with championship aspirations. He provides battle-tested defensive depth and specialized skills that are proven to translate directly to playoff success, making him one of the most sought-after rentals available.

3. Elias Lindholm's Destination Decision

Another one of the most compelling nhl trade deadline predictions revolves around versatile centre Elias Lindholm. With his contract expiring, Lindholm is the quintessential high-impact rental forward coveted by every Stanley Cup hopeful. His ability to excel in all situations as a top-six centre makes him a premium asset for a team looking to solidify its lineup for the rigours of postseason hockey.

A trade for Lindholm is a classic deadline move to bolster a contender's depth down the middle. Teams with strong wingers but a need for a reliable, 200-foot centre see him as the perfect addition. This situation is reminiscent of past deadline deals where a two-way centre was acquired to round out a contender's forward group, such as the New York Islanders' acquisition of Jean-Gabriel Pageau or the Tampa Bay Lightning's move for Blake Coleman.

Why Lindholm is a Top Target

Lindholm is far more than just a rental; he's a coach's dream. His consistent offensive production, elite faceoff skills, and responsible defensive play make him a plug-and-play solution for any team's top two lines. He can anchor a power play unit, kill penalties, and take crucial defensive-zone draws against the opponent's best players, offering a rare blend of skill and tactical intelligence.

His value lies in his adaptability. Whether deployed as a first-line centre or a luxury second-line pivot, Lindholm elevates the performance of his linemates and provides matchup nightmares for opposing coaches. This makes him a significant target for teams aiming for a deep playoff run.

Actionable Insights for Contenders

General managers pursuing Lindholm must weigh the cost against his immediate and potential long-term impact. Here are several strategic considerations:

• Assess Centre Depth: Is your team one reliable centre away from true contention? Teams like the Boston Bruins or Colorado Avalanche could view Lindholm as the missing piece to solidify their forward corps.
• Evaluate Extension Potential: Acquiring Lindholm comes with the opportunity to negotiate an extension, turning a rental into a long-term core piece. This possibility increases his trade value and requires a front office to be prepared for significant contract negotiations. Exploring this before the trade could be a key factor, which will be a major theme heading into the 2025-26 NHL season.
• Analyse Power Play Fit: Lindholm has historically been a key component on a top power play unit. Contenders should evaluate how his right-handed shot and net-front presence would integrate into their existing systems to maximise his offensive contributions.

Ultimately, acquiring Elias Lindholm is a statement of intent. It requires a package likely built around a first-round pick and a top prospect, but it provides a contender with a proven, versatile, and highly effective centre to chase the Stanley Cup.

4. Noah Hanifin Trade Market Emergence

Another prominent name swirling in nhl trade deadline predictions is Calgary Flames defenceman Noah Hanifin. With his contract expiring and extension talks seemingly stalled, the Flames are positioned to move the smooth-skating blueliner to recoup maximum value. Hanifin's combination of age (27), puck-moving ability, and top-four defensive prowess makes him an extremely valuable asset for contenders seeking an immediate upgrade on their back end.

A trade for Hanifin is a move to bolster a defence corps for a deep playoff run. Teams needing a reliable, minute-eating defenceman who can transition the puck effectively see him as a perfect fit. His situation is comparable to past deadline acquisitions of pending UFA defencemen, where a team pays a premium for a high-impact rental who can log significant ice time in all situations, similar to the market that surrounded players like Oliver Ekman-Larsson in previous trade discussions.

Why Hanifin is a Top Target

Hanifin offers a rare blend of offensive upside and defensive reliability. He excels at exiting the defensive zone with possession and joining the rush, creating offence from the back end. His skating is elite, allowing him to close gaps quickly and maintain tight coverage against speedy forwards, a critical skill in the fast-paced Stanley Cup Playoffs.

As a pending unrestricted free agent, he presents an opportunity for a team to acquire a premier talent without a long-term commitment, though many suitors will likely seek a "trade-and-sign" scenario. This flexibility makes him appealing to a wide range of general managers, each with different long-term plans. More details about similar past trades can often provide context for potential returns; you can explore more about historical NHL trade market trends to see how deals for players like Hanifin have unfolded.

Actionable Insights for Contenders

Teams pursuing Hanifin must strategize how to best integrate his skill set and manage the acquisition cost. Here are a few key considerations:

• Assess Defensive Pairings: Hanifin thrives alongside a defensively responsible partner who allows him the freedom to skate and create. Teams should evaluate their current pairings to identify the ideal fit to maximize his impact.
• Evaluate Power Play Role: While not exclusively a power-play quarterback, he can effectively run a second unit. Contenders should determine if he fills a need on their special teams or if his value is primarily at even strength.
• Prepare the Trade Package: The asking price will be high, likely starting with a first-round pick and a top-tier prospect. Teams must be prepared to part with significant future assets for what could be a short-term rental.

Acquiring Hanifin is a significant investment, but for a team on the cusp of contention, he could be the stabilizing force on the blue line that pushes them over the top. His versatility and two-way game make him one of the most coveted defencemen available.

5. Sean Monahan Veteran Rental Movement

Another of the most compelling nhl trade deadline predictions involves the movement of veteran centre Sean Monahan from the Montreal Canadiens. As a pending unrestricted free agent on a rebuilding team, Monahan represents the ideal rental player: a skilled, experienced forward who can provide immediate value to a contender without a long-term commitment. His resurgence in Montreal has positioned him as a valuable asset for teams needing to bolster their forward depth for a playoff push.

Acquiring a player like Monahan is a classic deadline strategy for contenders seeking to solidify their lineup down the middle. He provides a reliable, two-way presence that can stabilize a third line, contribute on the power play, and take crucial faceoffs. This type of move is comparable to past rentals like the additions of Nick Foligno or Lars Eller, where a veteran is brought in to fill a specific, high-leverage role and add invaluable postseason experience to the locker room.

Why Monahan is a Top Target

Monahan’s value lies in his versatility and proven track record. He's a low-risk, high-reward acquisition who has demonstrated a return to form after battling injuries. His strong faceoff percentage, net-front presence on the power play, and responsible defensive game make him a plug-and-play solution for any contending team looking to improve its centre depth.

His affordable contract and the Canadiens' clear position as sellers make a trade almost inevitable. For a reasonable package, likely a second or third-round pick plus a mid-level prospect, a team can add a player who was once a consistent 30-goal scorer.

Actionable Insights for Contenders

Teams interested in Monahan should focus on how he fits their specific needs for a deep playoff run. Here are a few strategic considerations:

• Assess Centre Depth: Is your bottom-six struggling to produce or win key defensive draws? Teams like the Colorado Avalanche or Boston Bruins could see Monahan as the perfect third-line centre to take pressure off their top stars.
• Evaluate Power Play Needs: Monahan excels as a net-front or "bumper" option on the power play. If a team's second power-play unit is underperforming, his skill set offers an immediate and significant upgrade.
• Consider the Character Element: Monahan is highly respected for his professionalism and leadership. Adding a player of his calibre can provide a calming influence and veteran poise to a dressing room gearing up for the rigours of the playoffs.

Ultimately, trading for Sean Monahan is a smart, calculated move that addresses a common need for playoff-bound teams. He provides a dependable, cost-effective solution that strengthens a lineup in multiple facets of the game, making him one of the most sought-after rental forwards available.

6. Tyler Toffoli's Scoring Touch Trade

Among the more reliable nhl trade deadline predictions, the movement of a proven scorer like Tyler Toffoli is a recurring theme. As a pending unrestricted free agent on a rebuilding or non-contending team, Toffoli represents a high-value offensive asset. His consistent goal-scoring and power-play proficiency make him an ideal rental for a playoff-bound team seeking to bolster its top-six or top-nine forward group.

A trade for Toffoli is a classic deadline move to add immediate offensive punch. Teams looking for a secondary scoring threat see him as a seamless fit, capable of elevating a second or third line and contributing on the man advantage. This scenario mirrors past deadline deals for goal-scorers, including Toffoli's own trades to Montreal and Calgary, where he was acquired to provide an instant boost for a postseason push.

Why Toffoli is a Top Target

Toffoli isn't just a depth forward; he's a natural goal-scorer with a proven track record. His offensive instincts, quick release, and ability to find soft spots in defensive coverage make him a constant threat. He provides a team with a reliable finisher who doesn't need to be the primary driver on his line, making him an easy player to integrate into an established lineup.

His value is particularly high for teams whose power plays have gone cold or lack a pure triggerman. For fantasy hockey managers and analysts, evaluating his potential impact can be crucial. Using a fantasy hockey trade analyzer can help project his point production on a new, more offensively potent team.

Actionable Insights for Contenders

Teams interested in acquiring Toffoli need a clear plan for his deployment to maximize his offensive contributions. Here are some key strategic considerations:

• Define His Role: Is he a top-six winger meant to play alongside a top centre, or a third-line threat tasked with exploiting weaker matchups? His effectiveness is tied to placing him in a position to shoot.
• Power Play Integration: Toffoli excels on the power play, often from the bumper spot or half-wall. Contenders must have a clear spot for him on one of their power-play units to fully capitalize on his skill set. The asking price will likely be a second-round pick and a prospect.
• Deployment Strategy: Toffoli thrives with offensive zone starts and skilled playmakers who can get him the puck in scoring areas. Pairing him with a pass-first centre is a recipe for success.

Ultimately, acquiring Toffoli is a strategic move to add guaranteed goals. It’s a lower-cost alternative to landing a superstar but offers a significant and immediate return on investment for a team aiming to make a deep playoff run.

7. Adam Henrique Veteran Centre Addition

Another one of the most practical nhl trade deadline predictions involves veteran centre Adam Henrique of the Anaheim Ducks. As the Ducks continue their rebuild, moving a pending unrestricted free agent like Henrique is a logical step to acquire future assets. For playoff-bound teams, the 34-year-old represents a highly reliable, versatile forward who can strengthen their bottom-six and provide valuable secondary scoring.

Acquiring Henrique is the quintessential move to add experienced depth for a long playoff run. Teams needing a responsible two-way player to solidify their third or fourth line will view him as an ideal rental. His dependability is reminiscent of past deadline acquisitions that bolstered a contender's forward corps, such as the Barclay Goodrow trade to Tampa Bay or Jean-Gabriel Pageau's impact as a rental for the Islanders.

Why Henrique is a Top Target

Henrique is far more than just a depth piece; he’s a "Swiss Army knife" forward who excels in various situations. His strong hockey sense, faceoff prowess, and ability to contribute on both the power play and penalty kill make him a plug-and-play solution for any contending roster. His consistent production and veteran leadership provide immediate value in a high-stakes playoff environment.

His versatility allows a coach to deploy him at centre or on the wing, ensuring he can fill any lineup gaps that arise due to injury or performance issues. This flexibility is a massive asset during the gruelling Stanley Cup Playoffs.

Actionable Insights for Contenders

Teams interested in adding Henrique must assess how his skill set fits their specific needs. Here are several strategic points to consider:

• Evaluate Salary Retention: The Ducks will almost certainly need to retain 50% of Henrique's $5.825 million AAV to make a trade work. This makes him an affordable rental, but Anaheim will expect a solid return, likely a second or third-round pick plus a mid-level prospect.
• Assess Bottom-Six Need: Is your team seeking more defensive responsibility and scoring punch from its depth forwards? Teams like the Edmonton Oilers or New York Rangers could see Henrique as the perfect addition to round out their centre depth.
• Consider Special Teams Impact: Henrique is a proven penalty killer and can contribute to a second power-play unit. His ability to win crucial defensive zone faceoffs, especially while shorthanded, is an underrated but vital skill for playoff success.

Ultimately, trading for Adam Henrique is a low-risk, high-reward move. It doesn’t require the massive asset package of a superstar trade but provides a contender with a reliable, intelligent, and versatile veteran capable of making a significant impact on a championship run.

NHL Trade Deadline Moves Comparison

Item	Implementation Complexity 🔄	Resource Requirements ⚡	Expected Outcomes 📊	Ideal Use Cases 💡	Key Advantages ⭐
Jacob Markstrom Trade from Calgary Flames	Medium - contract and no-trade clause considerations	High - $6M AAV contract, retention possible	Reliable playoff goaltending depth with strong metrics	Contending teams needing immediate goalie upgrade	Proven playoff performer, veteran leadership
Chris Tanev Rental Move from Calgary	Low - short-term rental with simpler acquisition	Moderate - second-round and conditional picks	Defensive shutdown, penalty kill boost	Teams needing defensive depth and penalty kill improvement	No long-term commitment, versatile system fit
Elias Lindholm's Destination Decision	Medium - high acquisition cost and contract extension uncertainty	High - first-round pick or equivalent	Two-way scoring and positional versatility	Teams seeking center depth or wing flexibility	Positional flexibility, playoff experience
Noah Hanifin Trade Market Emergence	High - extension complexity and high trade cost	Very High - high-end prospect plus first-round pick	Offensive defenseman with skating and power play impact	Teams with strong defensive structure wanting offense from blue line	High ceiling potential, power play quarterback
Sean Monahan Veteran Rental Movement	Low - rental with flexible contract	Low - third or fourth-round pick cost	Veteran faceoff specialist and leadership	Teams needing third-line center and faceoff depth	Low-risk acquisition, mentorship for youth
Tyler Toffoli's Scoring Touch Trade	Low - scoring winger rental	Moderate - second-round pick plus prospect	Immediate offensive boost and power play specialist	Teams needing secondary scoring and net-front presence	Proven scorer, playoff clutch performer
Adam Henrique Veteran Center Addition	Low - rental acquisition with minimal risk	Low - fourth-round pick or conditional	Two-way veteran depth and penalty kill role	Contending teams needing experienced fourth-line center	Versatile, low cost, reliable contributor

Final Thoughts: The Ripple Effect of Deadline Day

The NHL trade deadline is far more than a single day on the calendar; it's a seismic event that reshapes the league's landscape. The moves made in these final hours will define Stanley Cup contenders, accelerate franchise rebuilds, and dictate the narratives that carry us through the postseason and beyond. As we've explored, the Calgary Flames stand as a central hub of activity, with players like Jacob Markstrom, Chris Tanev, Elias Lindholm, and Noah Hanifin holding the potential to alter the balance of power in both conferences.

Beyond the epicentre in Calgary, proven veteran assets such as Sean Monahan, Tyler Toffoli, and Adam Henrique represent critical puzzle pieces for general managers looking to add depth, scoring, and experience. Each trade carries its own intricate web of salary cap implications, prospect capital, and team chemistry considerations. The rationale behind each of our nhl trade deadline predictions is built on these complex factors, analysing which teams have the assets and the motivation to make a significant push.

Beyond the Predictions: The Unpredictable Nature of Deadline Day

While data and insider reports guide our forecasts, the true magic of the trade deadline lies in its inherent unpredictability. A single, unexpected move can trigger a chain reaction, forcing rival general managers to pivot their strategies. A team that was previously content to stand pat might suddenly feel the pressure to respond to a blockbuster acquisition made by a divisional foe. This domino effect is what makes the final hours so compelling.

The most successful general managers are not just reactive; they are masters of contingency planning. They enter deadline day with multiple scenarios mapped out, prepared for opportunities that may arise from another team's actions. For fans and analysts, this means the story is never truly set until the clock strikes zero.

What to Watch For as the Deadline Approaches

As the final day draws near, keep a close watch on these key indicators to stay ahead of the curve:

• Player Performance: A sudden hot streak or a minor injury can dramatically shift a player's trade value and a team's willingness to move them.
• Team Standings: A crucial win or a devastating loss in the week leading up to the deadline can be the final push a "bubble" team needs to become a buyer or a seller.
• Minor Transactions: Often, smaller trades for depth players in the days prior can signal a GM's intention to make a much larger splash.

Ultimately, the trade deadline is a high-stakes game of strategic chess. The decisions made will be scrutinised for years, with every trade creating a new set of "what ifs" and cementing legacies. The only certainty is that the moves made will have a lasting ripple effect, shaping not only the outcome of this season but the competitive framework of the NHL for years to come.

---

Don't just follow the rumours, get ahead of them. With PuckNStick's advanced analytics tools, you can dive deep into player statistics, team needs, and salary cap scenarios to form your own informed nhl trade deadline predictions. Visit PuckNStick to access the same level of data the pros use and truly understand the impact of every trade.